Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Ramon Allones Edicion Limitada 2015 Club Allones
#1
Cigar:
Ramon Allones Edicion Limitada 2015 Club Allones

Specifications:

Year of Manufacture/Box Codes: 2015

Country of Origin: Cuba

Wrapper Color: Colorado Maduro

Wrapper type: Cuban

Filler: Cuban

Binder: Cuban

Vitola: Club Allones (5.375x47)

Manufacturer/Distributor: Habanos S.A.

Factory: Unknown

Humidimeter Reading: 63%

Environment:

Temperature: 30 degrees

Humidity: 50%

Wind: N/A


Setting: My backup spot in the big, indoor smoke room.

Paired with: Iced coffee

Cigar Aficionado called it "Dark and rustic in appearance, this cigar weaves earthy elements of coffee bean and spice with sweeter intonations of honey and dried fruit." and scored it a 92

Medium textured, irregular, somewhat veiny, dark Colorado maduro wrapper with very visible seams, a medium texture, short cap/head, and a hard bunch.

Slightly tight cold draw with no discernable taste.

Overall, a somewhat unattractive appearance.

So, as you can see i definitely agree with the "dark and rustic appearance " description so far.

Lets see, 7 years later, how I describe the rest of the experience and what I score it.

Even burn, dark grey, strong ash, flat coal and only a slightly tight draw.

Ample smooth, cool smoke, and a very light but fragrant aroma of floral and wood.

Generous richness and body, mild strength and perfect balance of generous flavors of earth, wood and floral notes, and a generous finish/aftertaste of the same.

Overall of very good character, with a very good score of 91 out of 100.

And, as a trial, for the first time, here are my scores for each individual section so you can see where it did well or where it lost points, and how i arrived at the final score that I did.

TOTAL SCORES
Appearance/Construction___12____ 15
Flavor/Strength___24___25
Burn ___24____25
Aroma__4____5
Smoke ___9___10
Summary___18____20
TOTAL___91___ 100

And, i swear i "borrowed" this point scale below from somewhere, namely Cigar Aficionado, but cant find it anywhere in a really quick search. Suffice to say, I'm 99% sure I didn't create it. I am seriously considering doing some tweaking on it though, we'll see.

Any opinions on the scale are very welcome so I can adjust if enough people agree that I should like I'm considering.

100-point scale as follows:

97-100 = Outstanding
93-96 = Great
85-92 = Very Good
78-84= Good
70-77=fair
65-69= Poor
64 and below =Bad

[Image: 144828e9882d1635148042ff6cc6af2f.jpg]


I friggin love cigars
Reply
#2
I like your review & setup. I would touch base on each category in the review.
They call me The Mum - Jimmie the Mum
Viva Mumcero - Mahk 12/4/2010 - http://www.stogiechat.com/forum/thread-20737.html
Honorary Shield Brother
Weak people seek Revenge, Strong people Forgive, Intelligent people Ignore
Reply
#3
Nice review, thanks
No Justice, No Peace!
Reply
#4
Great review.  I too like the setup you're using.

I'm also jealous that you have a big, indoor smoke room.
If Sonny had EZ-Pass, he'd have survived that hit...
Never apologize mister, it's a sign of weakness. - Capt. Nathan Cutting Brittles
Reply
#5
(12-19-2022, 09:27 AM)Tonto Wrote: Great review.  I too like the setup you're using.

I'm also jealous that you have a big, indoor smoke room.

Dont be too jealous.  Its unheated and has 6 air conditioners blowing in the currently 12 degree outside air.
Reply
#6
(12-19-2022, 06:39 AM)Jimmie the Mum Wrote: I like your review & setup. I would touch base on each category in the review.

I actually do, i just dont label each section along with my comments,  so some people may not notice I am. I have a form i fill out as I'm smoking,  so everything is real time vs from memory,  and each section is seperated with characteristics that get checked, and then turned into written comments.

Attached is the form for anyone interested in seeing it.  Irs not pretty,  but i think it covers everything,  but I'm constantly adjusting things trying to improve it.


Attached Files
.docx   cw review form.docx (Size: 48.42 KB / Downloads: 5)
Reply
#7
Here's a flavor wheel:


[Image: The-CIgar-Authority-Tasting-Wheel.jpg]
They call me The Mum - Jimmie the Mum
Viva Mumcero - Mahk 12/4/2010 - http://www.stogiechat.com/forum/thread-20737.html
Honorary Shield Brother
Weak people seek Revenge, Strong people Forgive, Intelligent people Ignore
Reply
#8
(12-19-2022, 08:26 PM)Jimmie the Mum Wrote: Here's a flavor wheel:


[Image: The-CIgar-Authority-Tasting-Wheel.jpg]
Actually already have one, but never found it terribly helpful. I have the palate of a goat. Lol.

Discerning the flavors is always the hardest part of a review, as is aroma.

I friggin love cigars
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)