Your top five of all time

[carl609]

If you had to make a list of your favorite cigars, what would be your top five? I know its hard to put a "best" or "favorite" label on a cigar, since there are so many great choices available. Sometimes its more about the situation than the specific cigar. My favorites are always changing, but a few very memorable cigars that I would put at the top of my list are:

1. Padron Family Reserve 45 Maduro, the day my nephew was born.
2. Padron Family Reserve 45 Natural, the day my niece was born.
3. God of Fire Carlito
4. La Flor Dominicana Salomon
5. OR Fuente Anejo, this last Xmas

[Domniomaestro]

CAO La Traviata
Cain 550 Maduro
601 La Bomba
Opus X
Undercrown

[Comptalk]

Hmm...

Montecristo # 2 (Cuban)
Partagas Salomones (Cuban)
Opus X Robusto
Hemingway between the lines
Casa Fuente Corona

[Tonto]

Dammmm...now I have to think...How can I limit my list to only 5?

[nayslayer]

Four kicks
Cabaiguans
Fausto
Las calaveras
Padron anniversary Maduro 1964

[Nimage]

im new to smoking but ive had quite a few and right now im at

7-20-4 Hustler
Carlos Torano Exodus 1959
Rocky Patel Edge Maduro
Warlock
la vieja habana

[TheValKitty]

Tough one: pardon my spelling I am tired today...there are others, but this is what I've got off the top of my head.
Opus X Lost City
Camacho Scorpion
Anejo Shark
San Cristobal Revelation
O.S.O.K.

[Tonto]

This is a difficult question for me, as my mood & tastes change from time to time & so many other great cigars already listed..

For everyday smokes...in no order...
Sancho Panza Double Maduro
Oliva Serie G
CAO Brazilia Piranha
Litto Gomez Chisil or Chisilito
El Cobre
any other cigar in my humi

For special smokes...in no order...
Padrons  1926, 1964, 44, 45, or 46 (never had an 5oth or 85th)
Opus X (aged)  I've had some young ones (even 4-5 years aged) I thought were so-so & turned me off to them but I recently had a 10 year old that was wonderful
Oliva Serie S  (sadly they don't make them anymore & I've been out of them for some time)
Litto Gomez Small Batch
San Cristobal De La Habana El Principe or Oficios
Diplomaticos No. 4 or 5
Partagas 898v
Montecristo No.4
There are others, but these are in my head at the moment...
I tend to prefer smaller RG cigars...but I'l smoke almost any other RG

[Jimmie the Mum]

I think it changes from year to year.
For now one thing will never change,
Any Anniversary Padron,
Any cigar gifted to me by MaytagMan & Parkster,
Oliva V Meliano,
God of Fire,
Pig In The Blanket (Fonseca

[Tonto]

I think it changes from year to year.
For now one thing will never change,
Any Anniversary Padron,
Any cigar gifted to me by MaytagMan & Parkster,
Oliva V Meliano,
God of Fire,
Pig In The Blanket (Fonseca

Dammit...

I forgot about the:
Oliva V Meliano
God of fire
Liga Privada Flying Pig & Feral Pig

Any cigar gifted by MaytagMan & Parkster, that goes without saying!