free hit counter script
Video Gallery of fine cigar reviews from around the world from a variety of public sources
Navigation Menu+

My Father The Judge Cigar Review

Posted by in Cigar Review

Get Free Shipping on your Order of $75+ with code SAVESHIP

The Judge Cigar is an extension of the My Father core line. It features a Ecuadorian Sumatra-seed wrapper’, Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo binders, and filler tobaccos from 3 of the Garcia’s family’s farms in Nicaragua

According to Cigar Aficionado

“When the new line made its debut earlier this year at the International Premium Cigar & Pipe Retailers trade show, attendees were able to view the box-pressed cigar, but the band and packaging were still being tweaked.

The Judge, which is an extension of the core My Father brand, will be differentiated from its predecessor by a chestnut-colored secondary band with the words “The Judge” stamped on it. The boxes also features an ornate logo based on a Victorian lithograph from 1905 under the lid that depicts a dapper man dressed in Victorian-era garb, complete with a bow tie, smoking a cigar.

The Judge from My Father Cigars
According to José Ortega, vice president of sales for My Father, the name was inspired by a friend of the Garcia family who is a judge. The Judge, he says, is more full bodied than the original My Father. It is rolled with a light-brown, Sumatra-seed wrapper from Ecuador, Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo binders, and filler tobaccos that were cultivated from three of the Garcias family’s farms located in Nicaragua: La Bonita Two, El Pedrero and San Rafael.

For now, The Judge, which Ortega anticipates will begin shipping by late October or early November, is slated for only two sizes measuring 6 inches by 56 ring gauge ($12.10) and 5 by 60 ($12.40). The cigars will come in 23-count boxes.

“We did not want to over do it,” says Ortega. “With a name like The Judge, we needed the sizes to be larger and stand out. So we chose two sizes that we felt were imposing but not over-the-top.”

Like all My Father cigars, The Judge is made at My Father Cigars S.A., the Garcia family’s factory in Nicaragua.””

See All LeeMack912 Cigar Reviews:

LeeMack912 2014 Favorite Cigars over $7.00:
LeeMack912 2014 Favorite Cigars under $6.00:

Check out my new online Cigar Review Show “Meet In The Middle” on iROBUSTO

“Meet in the Middle” combines a cigar review with a cigar herf and is presented by Leander, Hyacinth and Mark. Each cigar review show features the opinion on one cigar in three 15-minute segments.

“Meet in the Middle” #mitmcigar is a cigar review show with a different spin on the normal cigar review.…

Please watch: “Sencillo Black Edicion Limitada 2013 Cigar Review”




  1. LeeMack, this is my first time to watch your channel and I love your energy and positive attitude! Keep up the good work. Subscribing and watching more videos soon!

  2. must v had a bad 1. I enjoy your posts brother. gonna start sharing some of yours in my fb cigar group. East coast cigar lounge. Enjoy your day.

  3. love the cigar reviews lee mack, :D

  4. Thanks for saving me money, you're the man LeeMack912! Have another great day…..

  5. I'm wondering if your cigar was too fresh now. I heard you mention ammonia. I didn't get that at all. I may let a few rest in my humidor and send you one as a free second try if you're up to it.

  6. Great video brother take it easy!

  7. This is why I love hearing different perspectives! I definitely agree that it's overpriced. It should be $9. But I enjoyed the peanut butter chocolate coffee taste. It really is a personal palate thing. I find Cigars to be very much like wine and food. Example – people seem to like Eiroa 20 years. I threw it out halfway in both times I tried it. LOL! Thanks for another awesome review!! I'm glad we're still partners with Davidoff Yamasa. LOL!!!

  8. I get a really loose draw on these too. & I've had it a few times.

  9. Yes!!!!! It was me who asked you to do this one. Thank you for honoring my request ~ Abe

  10. Tell it like it is mr lee mack912. Have a great new year.

  11. Here comes the sun (doo doo doo doo)
    Here comes the sun, and I say
    It's all right

  12. Good morning nice review I think you are the first I've seen to end a review mid review lol good job if it ain't working time to do something different This morning finds me enjoying a Man o War Virute while I to am a pepper head I like to easy into the day with the Virute now if you love pepper pick up a Man O War Dark Horse.

Submit a Comment

This is a Video Gallery of fine cigar reviews from around the world comprised from a variety of public streaming sources. All videos are streamed from their uploaded sources. All references to brand names, trade names or copyrighted material remains the property of the said owner. Photos, videos, content and images are collected from public sources as allowed by YouTube, Vimeo and other streaming services and also remain property of their producers. We claim no ownership of any video, review or any other content from these outside services.